For the love of the Guernsey breed


SHARPSVILLE, Pa. — Although every dairy farm is unique, some may consider Ealy’s Highland Farm in Mercer County, Pa., to be even more out of the ordinary.

Until about four years ago, Dan and Sherry Ealy were milking Holsteins. Today, their 88-cow herd consists of about 25 percent pure Guernseys, with the rest of the cows either a cross of Guernsey and Holstein, or grade Holsteins.

Confused? You’re not the only one.

“A lot of people think we’re crazy,” admitted Sherry Ealy.

“But the more we go along with this idea, the more confirmation we get — like this is what we’re supposed to be doing.”


To understand their decision to transition to another breed, the couple said it’s important to note that they both grew up with Guernseys.

Sherry’s mother and stepfather milked Guernsey cows, and Sherry can still remember showing the grand champion Guernsey at the Mercer County Roundup.

The Highland Farm, which has been in Dan’s family since 1898, was home to Guernsey cattle, too.

Harold, Dan’s father, decided to transition to Holsteins when he wanted to expand the herd with Dan’s sister and brother-in-law in 1991.

Part of the reason for the switch back then, said Harold, was because Guernseys were hard to find in the area and Holsteins were more readily available.

Dan returned to the farm after he graduated college in 1996, and Sherry became an essential part of the operation when they married in 1998.

The next 10 years brought four children — Dalan, Christa, Conner and Renee — to Dan and Sherry, and a growing sense that a change was needed to the way they were dairying.

Dan and Sherry had purchased the cows and equipment from Harold in 2004 and today continue to rent the land and buildings. Although they continued to help part-time until 2005, Dan’s sister and her husband decided to move off the farm in 1999, enabling Dan, Sherry and their children to move into the farm house.

With the increasing daily challenges of being a dairy farmer, Sherry came to a life-changing realization shortly after they purchased the cows from her father-in-law.

“If you’re going to farm and you don’t love it, you better change what you’re doing,” she said.

For the Ealys, that change was going back to Guernseys.

“We just thought that there must have been a reason why God brought two Guernsey breeders together,” Sherry said.


The Ealys purchased a herd of about 40 Guernsey cows, yearlings and calves in October 2004 to begin the switch. The herd came from Bill and Janis Budner and their son George in Daisytown, Pa. Sherry said she and Dan were touched by the kindness and encouragement of the Budner family.

“They gave our kids rope and show halters and feed tubs, and they asked if they could purchase lifetime membership to the American Guernsey Association for each of the kids,” she said. “It was just so cool for them to believe in us like that.”

Although some of the animals adapted well, others didn’t, which is common in many transitions. Only three animals from that original herd of 40 remain at the Ealys today, but they were able to keep the quality genetics through some decedents.

Sherry said it was difficult to find Guernseys that were raised in a freestall operation, so the next step was crossbreeding.

“We know it’s going to take us a lot longer to get where we want to be, but it’s easier to manage our finances this way,” Sherry said.

Their goal in their breeding program is to keep the width, strength and correctness in feet and legs of the Holsteins while maximizing the dairyness of Guernseys. They hope to be 100 percent Guernsey within 10 years.

The couple believes a Guernsey milking 14,000 pounds of milk is just as profitable as a Holstein milking 20,000 pounds of milk because it takes less feed for the Guernsey to produce that amount than the Holstein.

“Right now, we’re feeding for 10 less cows than we actually have,” Dan said.

Since beginning to transition, the Ealys have noticed some improvements in the herd.

The Guernsey-Holstein crosses have a lower somatic cell count, better calving ease and a lower cull rate than the Holsteins. The purebred Guernseys seem to be more tolerant to the heat than the crosses and the Holsteins.

Commercial vs. show cow

The Ealys look forward to continue showing their Guernseys and would eventually like to market them, but they know milk production and longevity needs to be just as important as type.

“I agree with those who say there’s a bridge between commercial cows and show cows,” Sherry said.

The Ealys said selecting the genetics and deciding which bulls to mate with certain cows has been a bonding experience for them.

“I’ve learned how to read proofs and about the aAa program,” Sherry said. “It’s definitely fun for me and it’s been a marriage builder.”

“There’s something really satisfying about being the breeder of your animals,” added Dan.

Passing the torch

The Ealys hope their four children will develop a fondness for the breed in the same way that they got the Guernsey bug from their parents, and they believe a big part of that interest comes from developing connections with other Guernsey breeders.

Their oldest, 9-year-old Dalan, has been showing his 4-H calves and participating at the state Guernsey convention, and the family is looking forward to September, when they will travel to Harrisburg for the All-American Dairy Show.

Big dreams

The Ealys are hopeful their show days won’t stop at the All-American. Some day, they hope to take animals to the World Dairy Expo in Wisconsin.

They would also love to sell animals at the Blue Halter Sale in Bedford County and other well-known Guernsey sales around the area.

And Sherry hopes that some of her children, if not all four, remain involved in the dairy industry.

“If in 20 years, we’re still milking Guernseys, one of the kids is running a processing plant, and we’re putting our grandkids through 4-H, I’d be pretty content,” she said.


Up-to-date agriculture news in your inbox!

Previous articleYum!
Next articleUncle Honey was all thumbs
Emily Caldwell of Beaver Falls, Pa., serves as the 2009 Farm and Dairy editorial intern. She is a graduate of Penn State University, where she studied agribusiness and agricultural communications. Feel free to follow her on Twitter at


  1. thanks for sharing such a great story. way to go, dan and sherry, for keeping your family’s farm alive and thriving!!!

    i also understand the love of guernseys. the first calf that i raised was a guernsey and she was some milk cow.

  2. Sounds like you are well on your way toward your goals. We have had great success with crossing Guernsey on Holstein and continuing to work to registered Guernseys. They milk well with higher butterfat and protein levels and some have developed into great show cattle as well. Then if you can develop a direct market for your high quality milk and beef, you can really increase your profits without having to increase your farm size and at the same time provide management areas for your 4 children to grow into. Your family’s future looks bright with a great lifestyle and business. Congrats!

  3. I love Guernseys also…however I have a very hard time understanding WHY anyone would cross-breed a holstein with a wonderful Guernsey! Holsteins have A1 milk which is NOT good milk…and the Guernseys have the best A2 milk which is the healthiest milk of all! I wish people would do their homework before they do all this cross-breeding! NOT GOOD to CROSS A1 milkers with A2 milkers!

    • Hi Linda
      What the Ealy’s are doing is perfectly acceptable and if you really think about it, their goal is a 100% Guernsey herd. They are taking Holsteins and breeding Guernsey bulls to them so in that way they are perpetuating the Guernsey breed, and making more Guernseys!!! It takes a very long time to do this so you should applaud the patience and diligence of the Ealy family in their work.
      By the time the Holstein genes are gone, they will have A2/A2 Guernseys. (mostly as some Guernseys are A1/A2)
      The Ealys are wonderful people.

  4. I just looked at the last picture of the Ealy family in front of the farm sign – that is Copper (the calf) and we bought her from the Ealy’s almost 3 years ago.
    She is a great cow! Thanks Ealys!!

  5. Hello,

    We live 45 miles south of Lynchburg, Virginia and we are looking for a young heifer we could raise and milk. Would you have any calves available for sale? We would come up with a livestock trailer to bring her home.

    Thank you,


We are glad you have chosen to leave a comment. Please keep in mind that comments are moderated according to our comment policy.

Receive emails as this discussion progresses.