Cold or flu? Visit doctor, not the ER


UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — During cold and flu season, most of us inevitably will experience one or more acute illness. Fortunately, most acute problems are treatable without hospital admission. 

But many people use the emergency room (ER) for problems that are far better suited for their primary care doctor. 

“The ER is best equipped for what the name stands for — emergencies,” said Ryan Ridenour, family physician and member of the Penn State Hershey hospitalist team at Mount Nittany Medical Center in State College.

“When used for what it is designed to treat, patients often find the ER to provide excellent care with good outcomes, and typically a lot of the cost is covered by insurance.” 

When patients use the ER for unnecessary purposes, he says, the same level of care often comes with a far longer wait and much higher cost than anticipated. 

See doc instead

Efficient, cost-effective care for most illnesses can be received with a visit to your primary care doctor. 

If something feels life threatening (such as chest pain, stroke-like symptoms, shortness of breath, or a high fever and confusion in a child), Ridenour advises you go to the emergency room. However, illness such as a sinus infection, bronchitis, pneumonia or an ear infection can be treated by your primary care physician. 

Since a primary care doctor already knows you and your history, he or she will be less inclined to order as many diagnostic tests, which in turn keeps costs lower. 

For instance, the cost to diagnose and treat bronchitis in the ER is on average $460 compared to approximately $60 when treated in an office setting, Ridenour says.

Additionally, since you have a relationship with your primary care doctor, follow up and treatment plan changes are often easier if you’re not getting better as quickly as expected.

Get our Top Stories in Your Inbox

Next step: Check your inbox to confirm your subscription.



We are glad you have chosen to leave a comment. Please keep in mind that comments are moderated according to our comment policy.

Receive emails as this discussion progresses.