Shalaway details his favorite bird feeders

bird feeder hanging in tree during winter

When readers ask for help selecting a bird feeder, I’m happy to oblige. I bought my first feeder in 1978, so I’ve had lots of experience evaluating them.

I won’t presume to identify the “best” feeders, but I can name my favorites in both general and specific terms.

No wood

My first bit of advice is to avoid feeders made of wood. Though wood feeders are popular and aesthetically pleasing, wood acts like a sponge. It absorbs the oils found in virtually all seed products. It takes time, but eventually the oils impregnate the wood. The associated odor is a magnet for squirrels, chipmunks and bears. Rather than have critters literally eating my feeders, I gave up on wood products years ago.

Other materials

Today I use feeders made of polycarbonate plastics, metal and recycled plastic “wood” exclusively. If you are just beginning to feed birds, I suggest tube feeders made by Droll Yankees ( or Aspects ( I prefer these manufacturers because they’ve been in business for decades, they make their feeders in the U.S. and they stand behind their products.

Fill a tube with black-oil sunflower seed and birds will come. That first feeder I bought in 1978, by the way, was a Droll Yankees tube, and I still use it.


It looks its age, but it’s still perfectly functional. The “All Weather Feeder” by GoldCrest is an oversized tube that is truly weatherproof and perfect for dispensing sunflower kernels. Kernels are expensive and spoil quickly when wet, so it’s important to keep them dry.

Wire mesh nut feeders

I consider stainless steel wire mesh nut feeders to be modified tubes, and I highly recommend them. Filled with shelled nuts, nut feeders attract an endless parade of woodpeckers, chickadees, titmice and nuthatches.

Platform and hopper feeders are usually made from wood. I use these types of feeders, but only those made from recycled plastic “wood.” This material costs more than wood, but it’s easy to clean and lasts almost forever, so it’s a good value.

Hopper feeders

If you choose to go with platform and/or hopper feeders, remember that they are non-exclusive — all birds can use them. Unfortunately, these feeders can be dominated by pigeons, crows, doves, blue jays and squirrels.

Bowl feeders

Bowl feeders hang beneath a squirrel baffle and lack perches. That’s why only smaller, acrobatic birds with strong clinging feet can use them. Fill bowls with shelled nuts or sunflower kernels to attract woodpeckers, chickadees, titmice and nuthatches.

For years my favorite bowl style feeder has been Droll Yankees’ “Big Top.” It fills quickly and easily even in cold weather, it holds a lot of seed and it excludes larger birds such as pigeons, doves and grackles. Fill it with sunflower seeds, kernels and shelled nuts.

Window feeders

Window feeders that attach directly to a window pane are great for kids and anyone who is housebound. They can bring birds within just a few feet of the dining room table or a bedroom window.

Suet baskets

Plastic-coated and stainless steel wire suet baskets are inexpensive and durable, and no backyard should be without at least one. Chickadees, titmice, nuthatches and woodpeckers are among backyard suet lovers.

Droll Yankees

Today my number one favorite feeder is the Covered Platform Feeder by Droll Yankees. It’s only been on sale for about a year. It consists of a one-inch deep, 13-inch circular polycarbonate tray covered by a movable dome. The dome can be lowered to exclude bigger birds, and it protects the food from rain and snow. The tray can be filled with seed, nuts, mealworms, fruit or even suet.

Sunflower seeds

And I’ve found that when I fill the tray with sunflower seeds, birds rarely empty it by the end of the day. The best thing about the Covered Platform Feeder is that there’s no place to hide. On many feeders, birds get shy and use the far side of the feeder to stay out of view.

Easy viewing

The metal post that connects the tray to the dome is only 3/16-inch in diameter, so I can always see all the birds on this feeder.

Get our Top Stories in Your Inbox

Next step: Check your inbox to confirm your subscription.
Previous articleA big man who had a big man's voice
Next articleHome alone
Scott Shalaway, who holds a Ph.D. in wildlife ecology from Michigan State University, writes from his home in rural West Virginia. A former faculty member at Oklahoma State University and the University of Oklahoma Biological Station, he has been writing a weekly nature column for newspapers and freelancing for magazines since 1986. He can be heard on Birds & Nature from 3-4 p.m. Sunday afternoons on 620 KHB Radio, Pittsburgh, or live online anywhere at, or on the Tune-In radio app. Visit his website at or contact him directly at or 2222 Fish Ridge Road, Cameron, WV 26033.



We are glad you have chosen to leave a comment. Please keep in mind that comments are moderated according to our comment policy.

Receive emails as this discussion progresses.