Columbiana, Carroll Co. landowners sue Encino Energy over royalty checks

Natural gas drilling rig

UPDATE: The Zehentbauer family, Hanovers Farms and Evelyn Frances Young asked that their case against Encino Energy be voluntarily dismissed April 20, 2020 after the judge ruled on a similar case against Chesapeake Energy.

U.S. District Court Judge Benita Y. Pearson, in Youngstown, ruled March 30 in favor of Chesapeake and its predecessor Ohio Buckeye Energy. The landowners appealed to the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati, but when Chesapeake filed for bankruptcy in late June, the appeal was frozen, according to reporting by the Canton Repository.

The landowners have a year to refile the case against Encino.


SALEM, Ohio — A federal lawsuit claims Encino Energy and its affiliates underpaid Ohio landowners at least $5 million for oil and natural gas royalties.

The proposed class action lawsuit was filed in U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio on Oct. 18 by attorneys representing landowners in Columbiana and Carroll counties.

The Zehentbauer family and Hanover Farms, in Columbiana County, and Evelyn Frances Young, in Carroll County, are the named plaintiffs in the suit, although there are 140 landowners represented in the class.

Encino Energy, Encino Acquisition Partner Holdings, EAP Operating and EAP Ohio are the defendants. The case was assigned to Judge Benita Y. Pearson in Youngstown.


Jackie Stewart, Encino spokeswoman, said in a statement that the disputed leases did not originate with Encino, but were acquired from another operator.

“These leases contain provisions that have been under review by Ohio federal courts for a significant amount of time prior to our arrival in Ohio,” Stewart said. “We are awaiting the courts’ ruling on these provisions before these matters can be clearly resolved.”

Houston-based Encino Acquisition Partners bought all of Chesapeake Energy Corp.’s Ohio Utica Shale assets for $2 billion in October 2018, which included 320,000 net acres and 920 operated and non-operated wells.

Zehentbauer leased 656 acres and 296 acres with Ohio Buckeye Energy, which later merged with Chesapeake. Young leased 166 acres with Chesapeake.

The Zehentbauer family is involved in a similar case in federal court filed against Chesapeake, regarding the same issues raised in this case.

Canton-based law firm, Krugliak, Wilkins, Griffiths & Dougherty, and Sandusky law firm, Murray and Murray, are representing the plaintiffs.

The issue

The suit alleges that Encino has been taking out a number of improper post-production deductions from the landowner’s royalty checks. Since Encino took over the Chesapeake leases in late October 2018, there have been deductions for things like gathering, processing, dehydrating, transporting and compression, according to the lawsuit.

Bill Williams, chair of Krugliak law firm’s oil and gas section, said the plaintiffs’ lease agreements don’t allow for post-production deductions.

Only government-imposed taxes and fees could be deducted from the royalty checks, according to the leases.

The deductions were significant — between 50 to 90% for the majority of people, Williams said.

There had been similar issues with Chesapeake, and many landowners were hopeful that things could change for the better once Encino took over, Williams said.

“It’s far worse than how it was with Chesapeake,” he said.

Encino’s response

Stewart said the changes landowners have seen in their royalty payments are due to lower commodity prices and an increase in transparency on Encino’s part.

She said in the last year, natural gas prices were down about 20%, ethane prices were down 48% and propane prices were down about 45%.

“When either or both happen, royalty payments decrease, sometimes dramatically,” she said in a statement.

Additionally, Encino adopted “greater royalty check transparency,” Stewart said. The company is sharing detailed information about how royalty payments are calculated.

If anyone has questions about their lease or how checks are calculated, Stewart said they should contact the company at 866-678-0551.

(Reporter Rachel Wagoner can be contacted at 800-837-3419 or


Up-to-date agriculture news in your inbox!


  1. with all the wells and all the drilling they did … how do we even know if they are getting it off of our land ? we could all be owed money

  2. we all are owed money but the powers that be with their new summer homes won’t do S%^&. I don’t and never will trust any of them. I have 3 wells that I listen to every night on my what use to be peaceful. My greedy neighbors sucked me into something I wanted nothing to do with. The gas and oil will screw you every way possible. I actually asked Farm and Dairy for help and never got any. So they really don’t care either

    • I think we are all getting ripped off but how do you prove it ? We can’t wish we would have never signed on with this scam !!

  3. Encino Energy knows what they are doing, they don’t care . They are filling their pockets and making profits hand over fists. They know they can keep this in the court system for years and who know if they will ever have to pay out what they owe us landowners.


We are glad you have chosen to leave a comment. Please keep in mind that comments are moderated according to our comment policy.

Receive emails as this discussion progresses.