House approves new rules for applying manure in Ohio


SALEM, Ohio — Farmers could soon face additional regulations on how they apply nutrients in Ohio — this time dealing with manure.

The Ohio House passed H.B. 490 Nov. 19, a wide-ranging bill which would set new rules for when farmers can apply manure and other fertilizers to their fields, and transfer the Agricultural Pollution Abatement Program from the Ohio Department of Natural Resources, to the Ohio Department of Agriculture.

The bill was approved by a vote of 73-20.

It would ban the spreading of manure or commercial fertilizer in the Western Lake Erie Basin when the ground is frozen, when the top two inches of soil are saturated by precipitation or when there is at least a 50 percent chance of precipitation in the weather forecast.

However, the law allows application under these conditions if the nutrients are injected into the ground, incorporated within 24 hours of surface application or are applied to a growing crop.

The bill would be in addition to regulations approved a few months ago by the Ohio legislature, which require farmers who apply manufactured fertilizer to more than 50 acres to be state certified by 2017.

Farmer support

Failure to meet the new rules could carry hefty fines. However, many farmers support what is being proposed, including the Ohio Farm Bureau Federation and the Ohio Farmers Union.

Farmers in the Lake Erie watersheds already try to avoid applying manure to frozen ground, and have long been working to incorporate the manure into the soil, to prevent runoff.

Farm Bureau said it supports the new rule because it benefits Lake Erie, and includes “practices that are workable for farmers, apply to a well-defined geography and include appropriate penalties for non-compliance.”

OFBF has had an active role in representing farmers’ interests concerning water quality since discussions began, and has consistently called for solutions “that are science based, economical and balanced.”

Public opinion

The organization recently conducted a public study, along with some partners, who determined safe drinking water is Ohioans’ No. 1 environmental concern.

The survey included 1,000 Ohio voters, 88 percent of whom said safe drinking water was very important — more important than protecting fish and wildlife habitat, repairing aging water systems, and providing adequate water for commerce and industry.

Data collection

Ron Sylvester, spokesperson for Ohio Farmers Union, said his organization was glad to see new rules for manure application, and said he was disappointed manure was removed from fertilizer certification bill (S.B. 150), which would have required farmers who apply manure to meet the same regulations as those who apply manufactured fertilizer.

Sylvester said farmers should have to supply more data about the manure they apply, although he agreed proprietary information about each individual farm should be protected.

He said OFU had worked with the Ohio Environmental Council to try to include an amendment that would have required farmers in that region to report how much manure their farms produce, and where it goes.

Sylvester said it is unclear how much of the problem may be from livestock manure versus manufactured fertilizer, because livestock manure is not under the same set of reporting rules.

“We would like to see more data being collected and reported and we would like to see that data be able to be aggregated in a nonidentifiable way,” he said.

Other efforts

OFBF has contributed $1 million toward a diverse Water Quality Action Plan, which includes a push to get farmers in the Western Lake Erie Basin certified by spring of 2015, more than two years ahead of the state deadline.

Other partners, including Ohio State University, have donated substantial amounts, as well, with the goal of protecting water and preserving agriculture.

Get our Top Stories in Your Inbox

Next step: Check your inbox to confirm your subscription.


  1. Chris–I’m sorry–I can’t help myself…Pollution Abatement Program, ODNR, EPA, all the “alphabet soup” outfits telling us what to do….

    We Ohioans have been getting “manured” from Washington, D.C and Columbus for years.

    The politicians want to treat us like mushrooms—heap manure on us and keep us in the dark!


  2. This will not change anything it is all part of an incremental way to put us out of bis. Of course people want clean drinking water that includes me !! Soon the govt. will operate everything and we will all be slaves to them , do they really think that by us stock piling manure in large amounts in small area’s is a good idea !!!!! whoops I better not give them something else to pass rules for !!!

  3. I have a brother in law dealing with a ‘new’ neighbor. The neighbors is a large conglomerate dairy operation
    Who bought the next door farm and immediately Doubled the the amount of dairy cattle on
    A limited amount of manure containment area. Apparently this operation hauls out manure non stop repeatedly all day. Recently the dust storms created by these tractors hauling manure has engulfed my brother in laws home and now he is concerned their
    Bad practices will destroy his property and is very unhealthy. What legal advice can you provide us.


We are glad you have chosen to leave a comment. Please keep in mind that comments are moderated according to our comment policy.

Receive emails as this discussion progresses.