How utility-scale solar came to Ohio

And how farmers and rural communities are dealing with it

5
1541
solar panels in brown county
Hillcrest solar farm is nearing completion in Brown County. It was the first to apply for certification from the Ohio Power Siting Board, and it will be the second utility-scale solar project in Ohio to become operational. (Rachel Wagoner photo)

MT. ORAB, Ohio — It started with an envelope in the mail. The first one came in 2012, Chad Hawk said. The envelope contained an offer to pay the Hawks to put some of their land into a solar lease.

Hawk told his wife, Melanie, he wasn’t interested. Corn and bean prices were high. It wasn’t worth losing their farmland to a bunch of solar panels.

Another letter came the next year, and the year after that. By 2014, the price of corn and soybeans had dropped and the solar lease looked more appealing, Chad Hawk said.

“I had a professor in college who said, “You’ve got to look at everything as a business,” Chad Hawk said. “For $1,000 an acre, I couldn’t farm it for that.”

The Hawks signed a solar lease in 2016 to put about 500 acres of their land in the new Hillcrest solar project, in Green Township, Brown County. The project is nearing completion, which means the Hawks will soon get the big payout.

“We went from farming corn and soybeans to sunshine,” Melanie Hawk said.

Leading Ohio

The 200 megawatt Hillcrest solar project was the first utility-scale solar project to submit a full application, on June 29, 2017, to the Ohio Power Siting Board, the regulatory agency that approves big solar projects. It will become the second project to be completed and operational.

Hardin I, in Hardin County, applied shortly after Hillcrest and was permitted around the same time, but it beat Hillcrest to the finish line by a couple of months. 

solar map opsb
A map from the Ohio Power Siting Board shows the status of all the utility-scale solar projects in the state as of April 16, 2021.

The two projects kicked off the solar boom in Ohio. Since Hillcrest and Hardin were approved in February 2018, 11 other utility-scale projects have been approved by the Ohio Power Siting Board, and 25 more are pending approval or in the pre-application phase.

Large scale solar projects are proving to be a boon for some farmers, like the Hawks. It’s reminiscent of the shale gas leasing boom that took place in eastern Ohio a decade ago.

These solar projects, and the massive acreage they cover, are also causing discord in some communities. Neighbors to the panels don’t always reap the financial benefits that the large landowners do, but they have to live with the new view.

Balancing those two sides is proving difficult in many rural areas, but it’s the new reality dozens of small towns across Ohio will grapple with for years to come.

Why Ohio

Ohio is a sweet spot for large scale solar development, particularly the western half of the state.

Doug Herling, vice president of development with Open Road Renewables, the company that developed the Hillcrest project, said there is a robust transmission system, and capacity within the grid to handle more power.

The process to get a utility-scale solar project, which is anything with more than 50 megawatts of capacity, approved takes place entirely at the state level. That’s attractive to developers, because it simplifies the permitting process. No jumping around from local to county to state approvals. It’s all rolled into one process laid out by the Ohio Power Siting Board.

There’s considerable need for electricity, Herling said, with Columbus, Cleveland and Cincinnati and other big cities spread across the state.

There’s also a demand for it. Many corporations have renewable energy goals. Amazon recently announced its investing in two more solar projects in Ohio. That’s in addition to the 10 solar projects, including Hillcrest, that it is buying power from across the state. Facebook is buying power from the Hardin solar farm.

The land

On top of all those things, there is an abundance of flat, cleared land and people willing to lease that land to developers in western Ohio, Herling said. Farmland is basically the perfect place to put a solar array.

It took nearly three years for Open Road Renewables to acquire all the land needed to develop the rest of the Hillcrest project. It started with letters, like the one the Hawks received, “explaining who we are, what it is we’re doing and why we’re interested in the area,” Herling said. “And then we see who gets back to us.”

solar panels in a field
Solar panels sit in a completed section of Hillcrest solar farm, April 21, 2021, in Brown County. (Rachel Wagoner photo)

Once the conversation starts, they get out in the community, meeting at kitchen tables and touring farms, Herling said.

Solar projects need big swaths of land near transmission lines. The rule of thumb for utility-scale solar land usage is one megawatt of capacity will take up, on average, about seven acres of land. That means the smallest utility-scale solar project would still take up 350 acres.

Only landowners with large acreage will get an opportunity to lease their land and benefit directly from the project. Chad and Melanie Hawk are the largest land contributors to the Hillcrest project, which has a footprint of about 2,000 acres. The panels sit on about 1,300 acres. There are 35 other landowners in the project.

According to the Hillcrest certification order, there are 111 homes within 1,000 feet of the project; 11 homes not participating in the lease are within 100 feet of the solar panels.

Hillcrest will pay about $1.8 million annually to Brown County, Western Brown School District and Green Township for 35 years as payment in lieu of taxes.

Golden opportunity

The Hawks both came from farming families. Chad Hawk runs a grain operation with his father and other family members. Melanie Hawk comes from a cow-calf operation, which she still operates on her parent’s farm.

They manage family land together, but bought their first farmland as a couple in the early 2000s. It was near Chad’s grandparents’ house and the main farm, where he spent much of his time growing up. The Hawks bought more land later on, eventually stringing together more than 500 contiguous acres in Brown County, just over the county line with Highland County. They lived nearby in the small town of Buford.

Farming is full of ups and downs. Some years went well. Other times, “we hit some rough years where it was like, ‘Oh my God, are we going to make it?” Melanie Hawk said. But they made it work. In addition to farming, Chad Hawk also works for Nutrien Ag Solutions.

hawks stand in front of grain bins
Melanie and Chad Hawk, pictured April 21 at the Hawk family farm, are the largest land contributors to the Hillcrest solar project, in Brown County. Hillcrest is one of the first utility-scale solar projects to be built in Ohio. (Rachel Wagoner photo)

When the opportunity came to put their land in the solar lease, they weighed their options. Solar leases pay landowners a smaller rate per acre to hold the land while the project is developed, permitted and built. The big checks with the higher per acre rate begin once the project is operational. It’s likely that not all the solar projects in the Ohio Power Siting Board queue will be built. Some farmers won’t see that big payday at the end. The Hawks knew that going in. They weren’t desperate for the money from the solar lease.

“We knew, on a perfect year, what we made per acre,” Melanie Hawk said. “And when they came to us and offered us $250 more per acre, it was a no brainer.”

If the project was built, they wouldn’t have to worry anymore about commodity markets or the weather. They could continue farming with family and enjoy it.

The Hawks hired a lawyer familiar with energy leases, recommended by Ohio Farm Bureau Federation, to craft a contract. It took several months to get the right wording. They wanted to make sure their land was protected and their neighbors were taken care of, Melanie Hawk said.

Building it

Hillcrest is a patchwork of panels between State Route 286, Greenbush Road, US Route 68 and State Route 134. The panels sit in four different sections, each fenced off with chain link fence topped with rows of barbed wire.

PCL Construction Services, a global construction company based in Denver, is building the solar farm. Panels are still being installed in one section, but the others are complete and being commissioned, said Bill Behling, director of project development with Innergex, the company that built and manages Hillcrest. In all, there will be about 600,000 panels installed. It’s expected to be done and operational sometime in May.

Construction began in January 2020. That’s when hundreds of workers descended on the tiny rural towns of Buford and Mt. Orab.

With the construction phase, came problems: increased traffic and noise, workers speeding and littering, dirt and rocks being strewn all over the roads. Those are just a few of the complaints lodged with Innergex and reported to the Ohio Power Siting Board in a quarterly complaint report.

Amanda Widmeyer filed a complaint after a worker from the site drove off the road and got stuck in a ditch at the end of her yard. She said the worker knocked on her door at 6 a.m. to see if her husband could pull his vehicle out.

solar workers at hillcrest
Workers mount a solar panel on the Hillcrest solar project, in Brown County, Ohio, April 21, 2021. The project is nearing completion. (Rachel Wagoner photo)

“He’s trying to get out of the ditch, he’s tearing up my yard, leaving fluids everywhere,” she told Farm and Dairy. “Eventually, a company truck came and pulled the vehicle out.”

The worker who got stuck in Widmeyer’s yard was identified and fired, after other neighbors also reported he was speeding and driving recklessly.

A couple neighbors told Farm and Dairy how loud it was last summer when the posts for the racking system were being driven into the ground.

“It was a couple months of continuous noise,” said Eddie Jones, who has panels right behind his house. Though, he said he doesn’t mind the panels now.

Construction is winding down, but trucks, skid loaders and other heavy equipment criss cross the roads throughout the day. A street sweeper runs periodically to keep the roads clear of dirt, rocks and other debris.

Time will tell

Once the construction crews leave, things will quiet down and the people living and farming around Hillcrest will be left with one another. The panels will track the sun across the sky for the next 35 years, making a faint clicking noise as they go.

The solar project strained the Hawks’ relationships with some farmers and other people in the area. Chad Hawk said they lost some rented ground because the Hawks’ participation in the lease.

“You just try to understand them, and they have to try to understand you,” Melanie Hawk said.

The Hawks will get their land back in 35 years. Or maybe not. Innergex has the option to renew the lease. Time will tell how the relationships with their neighbors fare.

When the pandemic began, they moved from Buford to Melanie’s parents’ home in nearby Hillsboro and bought her parent’s farm. That’s something they couldn’t have done without the solar panel money. Once the project is operational, they should be able to pay off all their debt in four or five years, Melanie Hawk said.

“[Chad’s] got mud running through his veins as much as I’ve got black Angus blood running through mine,” she said. “I told him, ‘Don’t be sad. For that price, we’ll buy him some more dirt to play in.’ We’ll continue to farm. We love it.”

(Reporter Rachel Wagoner can be contacted at 800-837-3419 or rachel@farmanddairy.com.)

STAY INFORMED. SIGN UP!

Up-to-date agriculture news in your inbox!

SHARE
Previous articleTown hall showcases opportunities for reclaimed mine land
Next articleThe great gift of grandchildren
Rachel is a reporter with Farm and Dairy and a graduate of Clarion University of Pennsylvania. She married a fourth-generation beef and sheep farmer and settled down in her hometown in Beaver County. Before coming to Farm and Dairy, she worked at several daily and weekly newspapers throughout Western Pennsylvania covering everything from education and community news to police and courts.

5 COMMENTS

  1. So glad that these Farmers made out financially well, while the rest of us have to suffer with the depreciation of our homes, the noise, because believe me they are not quiet when they start turning towards the Sun! Loss of our wildlife and our beautiful views that’s why we all moved out here. And not to mention the strangers around, one even attempted to break into my home, this would never have happened if the solar panels weren’t out here, we hate them! They are no use to us, they are nothing but an eyesore and have cost us money.

  2. I have extreme mixed feelings about the solar panels. But at the end of the day I have to go against it. This article is focusing only on one family. It so happens to be the ones to lease the most land. Of course its all positivity for them. They went from struggling hard working Americans (like most of us) to working financially stable Americans. There is so much land in Ohio where not many if any residential home would not have been affected much. Hillcrest solar farms happens to be right in the area where I grew up. I arrow head hunted in those fields as a child. (With permission from land owners) when I seen the panels for the first time about 2 months ago I stopped the video about half way. Put my head down and cried. First I thought about our land, that land was made to provide in a natural form by providing crops, second for the surrounding people. I’m a fellow brown countian and I can tell you vast majority of them were not ok with doing this to our beautiful, peaceful land. Sounds like they wouldn’t even be able to sell there homes to get away, there kids and pets lost land to roam and play. Peace and tranquility of grounding yourself with the beauty of a higher powers work is gone for them. I get it I really do. But the greater good went out the window. And nobody listened to the others that mattered here. Not to mention the ones that have no voices and got ran out of there safe places, so much wildlife out there to enjoy and hear. Not anymore. So going forward, “we, the people ” #1 need to come together because we are allowing this chaos to pull us away from each other. #2 we will not stop the solar panels we should come to the reality. And I do agree with clean energy/ power sources. I live on the ohio river with in a mile of just one of the power plants. The pollution in the river, so I’ve heard is upsetting. I know I’m only one person however, sometimes that’s all it takes is one. I’m asking for these big companies to just understand. Not stop what your doing but, just be able to see and have some understanding that’s all. And to ohio power siting to do the same when approving these panels on our lands. And try to agree to disagree and compromise. Everyone didn’t benefit from this in their own eyes. Maybe just let those people have space and not 100 feet from there home or yard. It seems you could spare a couple panels to be put some where in the other direction of the project. Remain open minded. And we all need to open our eyes and stay awake during this devastating times to protect ourselves and each other. Last even if you don’t think there’s is any. Read some articles and see the positivity the solar farms offer. Like clean energy. Because reality is this is only the beginning. There is much more to come. So being mad or negative for the rest of our time on earth is one of the world’s many downfalls right now.

  3. Look at all those mechanics Liens against the Hawks land due to the contractual agreements they signed with the solar company on the Brown County Ohio Recorder website. It ain’t their land anymore.

Leave a Reply to Patiently waiting g Cancel reply

We are glad you have chosen to leave a comment. Please keep in mind that comments are moderated according to our comment policy.

Receive emails as this discussion progresses.