GROVE CITY, Pa. — Judy Ligo climbed over the high tensile fence and into the pasture to check on a cow and calf pair. They were doing fine. It was as routine as brushing her teeth. Judy, 52, dug out her cell phone and started snapping a few pictures of one of her Highland cows that was for sale.
Then, that one day, she heard a bone-chilling noise.
Bandit, the Highland bull she had raised since birth, was starting to snort and she heard his feet pawing at the ground. Her instincts kicked in immediately. She knew she had to get out of the way.
Judy turned and saw Bandit barrelling at her, and she knew she was in trouble. She started running as fast as she could. She had to try and get out of the way. She knew it was going to hurt.
• • •
Affectionately known as the “cow whisperer” in the cattle world, Judy is no stranger to working with cattle, and is known for her fitting and showing career.
She and her husband John started a dairy operation in Mercer County but transitioned to beef after 20 years in the business. They breed Angus and Angus cross cattle and operate as a commercial cow-calf pair and finishing operation, and sell retail beef to consumers, grocery stores and farmers markets.
The couple have 400 head of cattle, of which 40 are Highlands.
Judy does most of the breeding decisions on the farm, and she likes to see the calves hit the ground, the result of her decisions.
Bandit, who was several years old, was the bull used in her Highland cattle herd. Judy had raised him from a few days old and had bottle fed him. She was comfortable, but always cautious, when she would get near him because sometimes he liked to play. But she never thought he would hurt her.
• • •
Dinner was over and it had just stopped raining. It was a rare break in the rainstorms that pounded western Pennsylvania and eastern Ohio in June, so John went to check cattle at one of their other farms. Judy decided to slip out to the pasture to check on a cow that had just given birth, and to take pictures of one of their Highland cows for a prospective buyer from Washington state who had called earlier in the day.
She grabbed her phone and started down the long, gravel lane. Her bull, Bandit was in the pasture, but he was always in the pasture.
• • •
She was running toward the fence full speed, but before Judy could get out of the pasture, Bandit picked her up with his head and horns and started throwing her around like a rag doll.
Her cell phone flew from her hand and when it hit the ground, the camera’s video recorder turned on, recording mostly sky, but capturing the attack’s horrific audio.
In the recording, she screams out for him to stop, to no avail. He won’t stop — just continues throwing her around with his horns.
• • •
Some say guardian angels come in all sizes and shapes, but that one day, Judy Ligo’s took the shape of a 12-year-old Highland cow, Antonia.
As Bandit pummeled Judy, she is not sure if she blacked out or not, but she remembers laying on the ground and hearing Bandit charging back at her. She looked up, and saw two cows. One of them was Antonia.
Antonia bellowed and got in front of the bull before he could gore Judy.
It was enough to give Judy a break to scramble to her feet and try to get out of the pasture.
• • •
At the neighbor’s across the street, a young boy visiting from western Ohio happened to be playing outside.
He heard her screams, ran inside and told the adults a bull had just attacked a lady.
The neighbor man reached Judy as she neared the fences. By now, her pain had started and she was grabbing her shoulder and her chest. In the background, Bandit continued to snort and bellow as he stomped at the ground. With the neighbor’s help, Judy navigated the set of fences, climbing over and under the high tensile fence and across another open pasture to get to her driveway. She was just happy to have survived.
As Judy sat along the edge of the driveway, it started raining again. Lightning struck across the street and she could feel the electricity in the air, punctuating the nightmare.
• • •
The neighbor called John and calmly explained that Judy had been attacked by the bull, but she had gotten away and crawled out of the pasture on her own.
John thought it couldn’t be that bad if she was able to stand up and get out of the pasture on her own. In his mind, she has been in the pasture thousands of times before and nothing had happened, so this couldn’t be that severe. But he quickly finished his chores and headed home.
In hindsight, he and Judy agree, they should have called an ambulance.
• • •
John stopped along their long driveway and picked up Judy in the pickup truck.
When she turned her head, he thought something was wrong, but then just figured it was a matter of bruises and swelling. He got her in the house, propped her up with pillows and gave her some Ibuprofen. They both thought the pain would subside and she would be fine.
“There was no way to see the extent of the injuries,” said John.
An hour later, Judy asked to go the emergency room in nearby Grove City, Pennsylvania.
• • •
Judy walked into the emergency room without assistance. They put a gown on her and said she would have to wait — the emergency room was packed with accidents that night because of the rainy weather.
A few hours later, an X-ray revealed injuries both Judy and John never expected: a broken neck and broken ribs.
The tests showed fractures in both the sixth and seventh vertebrate in her neck, and broken ribs, but the severity of each injury was unknown.
Before she knew it, she was placed on a backboard with a brace and was being transported by ambulance to Allegheny General Hospital in Pittsburgh, to see a neurosurgeon.
“I asked them, why couldn’t we just drive there? It just seemed liked a waste to have an ambulance take me there,” said Judy, still not realizing the extent of her injuries.
• • •
The ribs would heal by themselves with time, but the doctors determined the injuries to her neck would not. After being in the hospital for three days, doctors decided surgery was needed.
Besides her neck and rib injuries, the MRI revealed one more injury: One of the main arteries in her neck was crushed during the attack. Instead of having two arteries servicing her brain, she would live the rest of her life with one, which could mean compromised blood flow as she ages.
• • •
She was able to leave the hospital after only one week, but Judy had to wear a full neck and torso brace for eight weeks, followed by six weeks of physical therapy.
And through it all, the farm had to keep going. So Judy had to give directions to her husband on what had to be done and when, frustrated, because she was so used to handling her own share of the work, now she had to hand it off and hope everything got done.
Her first big outing after the ordeal was to the Mercer County 4-H Roundup for the livestock sale, and was astounded by the support she received from family, friends and the agricultural community.
• • •
“You live by degrees,” said John when he thinks back to that June day.
Nothing was different that one day except for the tiniest things.
“When you think about the possibility of what could have happened, you realize how lucky she was,” said John. “Judy survived that attack by the tiniest degree.”
As Judy thinks back to that one day, she wonders if there were warning signs or something she could have done differently.
She remembers how Bandit would always throw his hay around with his horns and wonders if that was a precursor to what would come.
She goes back to the days when Bandit was a calf and wonders if bottle feeding him had anything to do with the attack. Perhaps the idea of learning respect and what is his space and what was her space was lost somewhere along the way.
She has also wondered if the injections he endured as a sickly calf made him associate pain with her.
She still hears the bone-chilling bellowing Bandit made as he charged.
“He was all about attacking and killing that day,” said Judy. “I could have been completely paralyzed or dead.”
• • •
Judy believes that working with cattle is about respect. The cows have to have respect, and the humans have to have respect. It’s a two-way street.
It’s a lesson she painfully relearned that one day.
*** Behind the story: Judy Ligo was featured in our Women of Ag Series in February. The Farm and Dairy staff had decided to put a picture of her and Bandit on the front page of that issue. Here is Bandit just this past winter.****
Bottle feeding made this happen I have no doubt. I would never keep a bottle fed bull, stallion or ram. NEVER make pets of your breed sires. I have seen this over and over and had a friend who was killed by a bottle fed bison and another whose knee caps were broken by a bottle fed ram. I NEVER take my eyes off a bull in a field ever.
What happened to the bull? I cannot believe that he was not removed from the herd and slaughtered. If he was not the people are foolish.
They would be very foolish to keep such a bull. All bulls who are aggressive towards people should be culled. If they did it once they will do it again.
I have raised cattle all my life, many bum’s, that grew up. And loved them all. But I have learned they are animals, and always will be, no matter how much of a beloved pet they can become. I never ever trust a Bull, pet or other wise, in any breed of cattle! I have even broke them to ride, spent hours with them. That is the first mistake people make, they can’t believe there beloved pet has turned on them. It is not there fault, it is easy to trust them. It is not the breed, it is with any breed. They are a animal. Just please be careful and mindful of them at all times.
I think pet bulls are much more dangerous the a regular herd bull. Bulls should not be trusted at all but pets can be mean or think they can still play with you and get very dangerous. This bull needs to go to slaughter, not sold to another family. The next time it could be a child. He has found the fun now in tossing around a person.
Bottle fed or not a bull will protect his baby and his cows. This was a new calf…. The bull is doing what he knows…. A cow will do the same… I’ve seen friendly cows but with a calf will protect….. a horse will do the same…. always watch for the signs…. tension, nervousness all indications to get out….. these are cows and he’s a bull and this is his herd not hers….. just because he’s been friendly doesn’t mean he doesn’t feel he shouldn’t protect his herd….. this lady doesn’t get it…..
But for the grace of God, I was charged by a bull (not a bottle baby) in June and nearly lost my foot. He hit me on my lower leg, and literally knocked my foot off my leg and my bones outside my body. When I went into surgery, I did not know if I would wake up with a body part missing…. I really thought I would. Today (6 months to the day later), I am walking. I have been around cows, calves, and bulls for years, and it happened so fast. It is something for everyone who is around livestock to learn from. Just like driving a car, when you are around large animals, they are unpredictable and anything can happen (just as with other drivers)….but that doesn’t mean you quit being around them (or driving!). It has not made me fearful, but it has made me more aware that I am not indestructible, or like the article states…. how easily one small thing can change your world.
Thank you to Judy for sharing her experience with us. I am certain she is helping someone avoid a similar situation by reading about her ordeal.
Oh my goodness !
Blessings to you Judy and I’m so happy to know that you’re healing and that God sent protection over you that day. May this always remind us that anything can happen…. Keep your distance and Respect & Caution are of Utmost importance !
Bottle fed babies lose all their fear of humans, he liked to play with her because he considered her part of his herd. The smell of the blood of the new baby and the cows hormones also signals the bulls breeding instincts, and could cause him to see Judy as a challenge. What everyone seems to forget is the cow that saved her. She is alive, learned her lesson and passed it on. We never know when an animal, even one raised with humans all their life will revert to their basic instincts.
This is an amazing story Judy! I am glad you are allright I do however hope that this bull was slaughtered and not sent to another family. Blessings to you and hope you recover fully!
I would always drive my small Kawasaki Mule into the pastures to check on animals. At least you can use the vehicle as a shield, run to the other side, or get in and drive away. Ive had cows attack me too, not just bulls. They get protective. Going in alone is not a good idea. And a mean ram can do the same thing. Gotta keep your wits about you.
“Respect?” You’ve got to be kidding me.
When are people going to GET IT?!
You betray them, they’ll turn around and betray you.
It’s that simple.
I’m sorry she was hurt so badly. I really am. I wouldn’t wish pain and suffering on anyone and I’m glad she’ll recover, but I hope this incident will wake up her compassion and she’ll turn her decision making skills to better use.
Btw, don’t bother arguing, justifying, or defending your antiquated “raising to sell for slaughter lifestyle.”
Time seems to not be on your side.
All I can say is, you are an idiot. No need to reply with your crackpot notions about livestock farming.
Judy, happy you got away with only that. I have personally known two people here in Kansas that died working with cattle and both died when walking between cows and got crushed when other cows shoved the one they were beside. One was against a barn wall and the other one of those big rolls of hay.
“Betray them”? What the heck are you talking about? The lady has been caring for them for years. The only reason the bull attacked because she took her phone on the property with the newborn calve. She was a threat to the bulls heard. ( YES A PHONE CAN CAUSE THIS ) You are just a bitter person that has a problem with people. Your response is cold and ridiculous.
I’d never let my wife in the pasture with a ram or even the regular cattle. Even I would not be in a pasture with a bull without my truck or rifle. I read the other week about a woman who was researching grizzly bears and got mauled. These new fangled ways are dangerous, especially for the ladies.
I wish every animal rights activist could read these comments.
while I feel horrible for the attack, working with one of the most dangerous herbivores (if not the one and only outside of a vegan with an elephant gun) is a matter of personal discretion, knowing the risks, much like standing on top of a motorcycle on the highway…your doing something amazing…suddenly something more amazing happens..what you already feared.
I am well aware this can happen easily in the pasture. I have had a bull protect me from pushing cows, faced a charging bull and side-stepped so it passed me and thankfully kept on going. I believe the only thing Judy may have done is rub this bull on the head, which should never be done even when playing with calves. Cattle show affection by rubbing along the jaw to the neck. Great that she survived.
I just had a really friendly calm and young pointer killed by my best milking goat….I have milked her for more than 5 years she has had many kids and never shown any agressiveness, but last week, suddenly she ran across the yard, from 10 meters away and threw Raffa into the air, he wasn´t doing anything , just standing there…he died a few hours later from a massive hemorrage.
now I won´t let the children or the dogs into the milking pen at all.
Bless your heart. Man or woman, neither are a match for a pissed off bull. Or Grizzly Bear………My ex boyfriend was attacked by two different bulls, both times for doing what I told him not to. For some reason he believed because he was a man he could do things no cow savvy person would try.
So scary. My father raises Highland cattle and got tossed by one of his cows when another more dominant cow started pushing in. He broker his C4 and C5 vertebrae and had to endure spinal fusion surgery. He did sustain some nerve damage, but thankfully was not paralyzed. I help manage his chores during recovery and I will tell you, of his two bulls, the hand raised, bottle fed bull is by far the more untrustworthy of the two. He is pushy and thinks nothing of lowering his head and using his horns. I don’t like him one bit.