How to hide 8 million acres in plain sight


American farmers and global food makers have had more than a decade to get comfortable with wild, year-to-year swings in crop acres brought by decoupled, “freedom to farm” ag policies, an 800 percent boom in biofuel production and an increasingly hungry export market for American meat and grain.

A punch

Still, the 2009 Prospective Planting Report, released March 31 by the U.S. Department of Agriculture, held a punch no one saw coming.

According to USDA, American farmers will plant 7.8 million fewer acres of key crops this year than last. That’s a lot of acres growing nothing more than last year’s stubble and next year’s dreams.

It’s akin to European farmers not planting one square centimeter of Belgium and nearly half — the flatter half, one reckons — of Luxembourg.

On this side of the pond, the unplanted acres are just a million less than what will be planted to cotton, 8.81 million, this year. The cuts are as broad-based as deep, says USDA.


Corn acres will drop slightly, down 1.2 percent, while soybeans will show a modest boost. Plantings for most other crops, however, are forecast to fall; some to flat-out tumble.

For example, USDA sees sorghum acres down 16 percent, barley plantings down 6.6 percent, winter wheat off 7.3 percent, cotton down 7 percent, sunflowers down 17.7 percent, durum wheat down 10.5 percent and peanuts off by a whopping 26.7 percent.

Add all those downers up and 2009 total planted acres are 8.8 million acres less than 2008.

Increased plantings in rice, hay, oats (come on, oats?) soybeans and sugarbeets, however, trim that total to 7.8 million.

If you let professional market watchers scratch your head over the drop, though, most will be done long before you.

Why? If you subtract the huge acreage increases farmers unleashed in 2007 and 2008 due to soaring corn prices, says Darrell Mark, an extension marketing specialist at the University of Nebraska, 2009’s total is “nearly in-line with plantings seen from 2003 to 2006” when market prices were — like this year so far — more modest.

Hiding in plain sight

As such, he says, the nearly 8-million-acre drop reported by USDA is hiding in plain sight.

“I suspect farmers answered USDA’s questions truthfully,” explains Mark. “Given the much higher planting costs this year and moderate market prices, they truly don’t know their complete crop acres or mix yet.”

Certainly, he adds, planted acreage could drop dramatically this year compared to last “because access to credit is an issue and some farmers may be facing a credit crunch.”

But, he suspects, “We will see a good portion of those ‘unplanted’ acres get planted into mostly corn and soybeans — not wheat and not cotton — as the season progresses because costs have dropped and markets are rallying.”

Most major commodity markets did rally on USDA’s short-acres report.

Key reversal week

In fact, technical analysts — those elves who follow price charts — viewed the March 31-April 3 Chicago futures action as a “key reversal” week: prices for all the major farm commodities, except hogs and Class III milk, according to DTN analyst Darin Newsom, took out their previous week’s low and high before finishing the week higher.

Chartists see that broad strength as a classic launching pad for a bull market.

Far less certain

I’m far less certain. Even if the projected cut in plantings occurs, American farmers will plant their third largest corn crop since 1949 and the largest soy acreage ever.

Trend-line yields for both, combined with ailing — and, by year’s end, conceivably weaker — demand might make this spring rally look pretty sweet come October.

And if the acreage cuts don’t occur, winter will be long, dreary and cheap.


Up-to-date agriculture news in your inbox!

Previous articleA Question of Mending (both body and health care system)
Next articleFeeding for pounds of fat and protein: That's all you are paid for
Alan Guebert was raised on an 800-acre, 100-cow southern Illinois dairy farm. After graduation from the University of Illinois in 1980, he served as a writer and editor at Professional Farmers of America, Successful Farming magazine and Farm Journal magazine. His syndicated agricultural column, The Farm and Food File, began in June, 1993, and now appears weekly in more than 70 publications throughout the U.S. and Canada. He and spouse Catherine, a social worker, have two adult children.



We are glad you have chosen to leave a comment. Please keep in mind that comments are moderated according to our comment policy.

Receive emails as this discussion progresses.