Ohio Holstein Association comes out of conflict renewed


(Scroll down to see more photos from the annual meeting.)

ALLIANCE, Ohio — It was a difficult year for members of the Ohio Holstein Association, but they made it clear at their annual meeting March 7-8 in Alliance they are ready to move on.

“This past year has been trying for the association,” said former president Tom Thorbahn, of Vickery, Ohio. “But it was something that we got through.”

The association found itself in default of $346,000 in May 2013, the result of a cattle contract that now-fired general manager, Don Alexander, reportedly entered into without the Holstein association’s consent.

In August, the association has signed a confidential agreement with New Jersey-based Nil Livestock Co., concerning debt owed to Nil for the sale of heifers in 2011.

For nearly three years, court documents were mailed to an address other than the official Ohio Holstein Association address, which is why the association’s board and members didn’t know what was going on.

The association, whose membership dipped approximately 80 people to 688 as of the beginning of March, is looking ahead, and opened the floor during its business meeting to members’ input into the type of paid administrator it now needs. The board has discussed the situation at length, but wanted to hear directly from members.

“We need a plan; we need a specific job description,” explained association vice president Randall Kiko.

Although various comments were voiced from the floor, no consensus or formal recommendation was finalized.

The current officers will continue into the second year of their terms, including Dallas Rynd as president; Randall Kiko, vice president; Cathy Berg, secretary; Lisa Kerr, treasurer; and executive board members Joe Miley, Lamar Liming and Greg Conrad.


During the Saturday awards luncheon, the association honored several members, including recipients of the Progressive Breeders’ Registry designation, high sales awards, junior awards, and All-Ohio and junior All-Ohio awards.

The association’s Distinguished Service Award was presented to auctioneer Steve Andrews, of Wooster, Ohio, who was unable to attend. A fourth generation auctioneer, Andrews is familiar to many livestock sale-goers, and he has cried many sales for the Holstein association and members.

Junior and senior Buckeye Breed Builder awards were presented to Adam Whiteleather and Tom Thorbahn, respectively.

Whiteleather, of Minerva, currently serves on the association board, and is part of his family’s 500-head registered Holstein operation

Thorbahn, of Vickery, Ohio, has been a member of the Ohio Holstein Association and the National Holstein Association for 40 years, and has served as president, vice president, treasurer, and on numerous committees for the Ohio association, and served as a director on the National Holstein Board.

ohio holstein.liming.2Mary Liming, of Lou-Ida Farm in Trumbull County, received the Ohio Holstein Woman of the Year award. This year marks the 97th year Lou-Ida has been raising registered Holsteins, and when Mary was young, her father, Lamar Young, gave her the job of registering the calves — a job she continues today on the farm, now operated by Mary and husband Lee Liming, as well as their son, Lamar Liming.

The Ohio Holstein Queen in 1956, Liming has spent a lifetime promoting Holsteins, encouraging farmers to register their cattle, even helping them draw the cattle pictures and complete the applications.

The Youngs, then the Limings, were fixtures in the show ring, and continue to show at the local and district shows, as well as the Ohio State Fair, and Mary is still the one to prepare the papers and plan the displays. She also does the farm’s accounting and computerized records.

In addition to the dairy farm, she has been active on community and church boards and committees, serving most of these as treasurer.

Special award

In a surprise presentation, the state association presented a special award to Columbiana County’s Bill McKarns for his lifetime love for the registered Holstein cow, and belief in the power of the state and national breed associations.Ohio holstein.mckarns

In 2007, McKarns received the Holstein Association USA’s first Distinguished Leadership Award in recognition of his passion and determination to open the national association’s registry to include grade cattle, an idea that wasn’t popular in the late 1980s and early 1990s. Today, he is recognized as the “Father of the Qualified Herdbook.”

In presenting the award, Bill Ramsey recalled being a delegate to a national Holstein convention when the idea first surfaced, and was shot down.

“But Bill, over several years of talking, proposing and determination, not only got grades ID’d, they got genetic evaluations, classifications, papers, pedigrees and a process to upgrade to higher value for every black and white cow in America.

“You were right, Bill, the process is working, and it never hurt the value of one single registered cow,” Ramsey said.

Queen contest

Four contestants — Megan Cornish, North Fairfield; Hannah Dye, Beloit; Allison Mangun, Burbank; and Morgan McDonnell, Wellington — vied for the honor of 2014 Ohio Holstein Queen during Friday night’s pageant, which included individual interviews with the judges and an impromptu question before the reception crowd.

ohio holstein.queen - Version 2Allison Mangun was crowned the new queen, assisted by runner-up Morgan McDonnell.

Mangun, 19, is the daughter of Roy and Lisa Mangun and is a student at Ohio State University’s Agricultural Technical Institute in Wooster, where she serves as vice president of the campus Buckeye Dairy Club. The current Ohio FFA state reporter, she has shown both Jersey and Holstein cattle at the local, state and national levels.

McDonnell, 18, is the daughter of Kyle and Becky McDonnell, and is a senior at Wellington High School, where she has been involved in the FFA. She has judged dairy cattle in FFA and 4-H, and is a junior member of the Ohio Holstein Association and the national Red and White Dairy Cattle Association.

Convention tours

After attending the Ohio Holstein Convention Sale, attendees were invited to tour the Whiteleather Holstein farm in Minerva and the Campbell Brothers farm in Homeworth.

At the Whiteleather farm, the family featured “Miss America,” along with her many daughters and granddaughters, in a tent where farm visitors could see the cow family lineage. Miss America, which is registered as Whiteleather Outside 367, produced 44,637 pounds of milk over 365 days. She is an outstanding flush cow who has 128 offspring.

The Whiteleather farm is home to 500 registered Holstein lactating cows, with a rolling herd average of 26,127 pounds of milk.

The tour also highlighted the Whiteleather operations, their double-12 polygon, or “pregnant,” herringbone milking parlor and various herd management practices.

Many visitors made their way to the Campbell Brothers’ farm to get a look at their operations. The Campbell Brothers Inc. farm is also family owned and came to Stark County in 1944. They milk 70 registered Holsteins in a sand-bedded tie-stall barn. The current herd average is 28,100 pounds of milk.

The herd has received the Holstein association’s Progressive Breeders’ Registry award for 27 years and its Progressive Genetics Herd award for 20 years.

In addition, the family farms 3,000 acres of wheat, soybeans and corn.

The tours also featured a Holstein heifer judging contest at each farm.



Up-to-date agriculture news in your inbox!



We are glad you have chosen to leave a comment. Please keep in mind that comments are moderated according to our comment policy.

Receive emails as this discussion progresses.